What is a Pugh Matrix, and what are best practices, tools and online templates for teams and organizations?

Excel file
Excel file

Download file or signup to get:

  • Interactive online templates
  • Full business processes
  • Dashboards & analytics
  • Team collaboration tools

Definition of Pugh Matrix

The Pugh Matrix is a diagram used to compare multiple product or solution designs and accurately determine which candidate will best meet a set of criteria based on business needs and customer demands. Upon completion of the Pugh Matrix, business leaders are better able to select a candidate for product development and simultaneously allow for qualitative optimization of tangential concepts through the creation of alternative “hybrid” concepts and designs. 

Description of Pugh Matrix

A Pugh Matrix is used when a business is assessing which design, concept or idea to pursue from a long list of potential candidates. The Pugh Matrix helps with the selection process by ranking which solutions should become priorities based on how important they are to the business and the customer. It is because of this focus on the customer that the Pugh Matrix requires input captured during Voice of Customer research prior to carrying out the matrix exercise. 

Stuart Pugh, a British product designer and engineer, designed the Pugh Matrix. The matrix provides mathematical rigor in the form of a decision-making tool used with DMADV Six Sigma projects, and it’s core purpose is to help business leaders validate multiple concepts while getting buy-in from senior stakeholders across a team for the final design of a product or service. 

The Matrix requires working with a team that is skilled in concepts of product design, voice of customer research, and weighting criteria. The decision matrix is designed to remove unconscious biases and opinions from the selection process and help teams make fact and number based decisions more effectively. 

Tools & Templates

The tools that business leaders, product managers and directors must use to enable the successful implementation of the Pugh Matrix are cause and effect analyses, process flow maps, and voice of customer insights.

upBOARD's Online Pugh Matrix Tools & Templates

Unlike most traditional process checklists and problem solving models, upBOARD’s online Pugh Matrix template allows any team or organization to instantly begin working with our web templates and input forms. Our digital platform goes far beyond other software tools by including progress dashboards, data integration from existing documents or other SaaS software, elegant intuitive designs, and full access on any desktop or mobile device.

Learn more about upBOARD’s full portfolio of online digital best practice tools and templates for specific topics, including business strategy, marketing, human resourcesoperations, innovationproject management, change management, and software development.

Learn more about upBOARD’s portfolio of other business strategy best practice tools and templates, including:

2 X 2 Matrix, ADL Matrix, Affinity Diagrams, Baker’s 4 Strategies of Influence, Balanced Scorecard, BenchmarkingBlue Ocean Strategy, Bowman Strategy Clock, Build-Measure-Learn Feedback Loop, Business Model Canvas, CAGE Distance FrameworkCompetitive Analysis, Competitive Landscape AnalysisContingency PlanningCore Competence AnalysisCritical Success FactorsDiscovery Driven Planning, Economic Value Added, First Mover Advantage, Five Forces ModelForce Field AnalysisGap Analysis, GE McKinsey 9-Box MatrixGo To Market Strategy, Hambrick & Frederickson’s Strategy Diamond, Hedgehog Model, Hook Model of Behavioral Design, Hoshin Planning System, Kay’s Distinctive Capabilities Framework, Key Outcome Indicators, Kotler’s Five Product Levels Model, Kotler’s Pricing Strategies, Lafley & Martin’s Five Step Strategy Model, McKinsey 7S Model, McKinsey’s Seven Degrees of Freedom for Growth, Mergers & Acquisitions, Mission Statements, Mullin’s Seven Domains Model, OGSM Framework, Ohmae’s 3-C’s Model, Partner Relationship Management, PEST Analysis, PESTLE Analysis, Porter’s DiamondPortfolio ManagementPurpose Statements, Pyramid of PurposeScenario Planning, Simonson & Rosen’s Influence Mix, SMART Performance Metrics, SMARTER Goals, SOAR, Strategic Goals, Strategy Map, Strategy Roadmap, Strategy Uncertainty MapSWOT Analysis, TOWS MatrixTriple Bottom Line, USP Analysis, Value Chain Analysis, Value Disciplines Model, Value Net ModelValues StatementVision Statements, VRIO Analysis, and Weisbord’s Six-Box Model.